Value of Rankings in Making College Decisions

Find your perfect value college is an advertising-supported site. Featured or trusted partner programs and all school search, finder, or match results are for schools that compensate us. This compensation does not influence our school rankings, resource guides, or other editorially-independent information published on this site.

High school students face many challenges while choosing the right college. They typically rely on Google searches that rank the best institutions. However, most rankings are not created equal. So, how can students determine which ranking is valuable and which one to consider when making their final decision?

In this article, we will examine the value of rankings in making college decisions.

Featured Programs

Value of Rankings in Making College Decisions

Prospective students pay close attention to college rankings. These rankings quantitatively assess an institution’s position in the academic environment and are often based on criteria like academic reputation, faculty quality, and resources. 

Students gathered on a table, busy planning and executing a group task

Rankings are helpful for students as they help them find schools that are best suited to their individual needs and interests. Higher-ranked colleges may offer a strong academic climate, research opportunities, and a well-regarded faculty.

Rankings also help prospective students understand the competition between colleges and their value in the job market after graduation. While rankings are a good starting point for college selection, they should not be relied upon as a substitute for personal fit and program offers. 

Factors Considered in Determining Ranking 

College rankings provide valuable information for parents and students considering different alternatives for higher education. These rankings provide a comprehensive picture of a college’s strength by evaluating several factors. Some of them are discussed below:

Academic Reputation 

College evaluators and guidance counselors assess the quality of undergraduate education provided by each college. Many universities approach these ranking websites themselves to evaluate their programs. The European University Association (EUA) surveyed 171 universities from 39 countries in 2014 and discovered that 75% used their rankings for promotional reasons. 

The evaluation is often based on intangible, qualitative factors such as the effectiveness of lessons and the level of student engagement. Despite the subjective nature of this data, it provides rating sites with a more complete picture than just relying on numbers alone.

Retention Rate

The retention rate is the percentage of first-year students who continue their studies and graduate within a specific time frame. This metric reflects how satisfied students are with their college experience. 

A supportive social and academic environment and ample assistance from advisors and administration in the first year lead to a higher retention rate. Conversely, students may drop out or transfer due to dissatisfaction or a lack of resources.

Instructional Resources

Factors such as class size, student-faculty ratio, faculty compensation, research achievements, instructional resources, and professor qualification can influence the quality of education. 

Teachers need to be supported financially and have manageable workloads to have a high-quality learning environment. Additionally, teachers need to be actively engaged in substantial research or recognized for their contributions to academia.


Ranking depends on a school’s selectivity level based on factors like admission rate, yield rate, class rank of applicants, and standardized test scores. These factors indicate a student’s academic motivation and potential impact in their respective fields after graduation. A high yield rate suggests intellectually gifted students prefer the school over other options.

A man in a cozy sweater engrossed in reading a book

Alumni Contributions

Higher alumni contributions typically suggest the students had a positive experience at the institution. When graduates feel appreciated and supported during their studies, they are more likely to give back to the school. 

A substantial donation rate points to a strong sense of school pride, an active campus community, and access to excellent academic and extracurricular programs.

Limitations of College Rankings

While it can be helpful to look at college rankings while you’re learning about schools, “The college ranking system is not without limitations,” explains Kelsey Ludeman, an education expert with 15 years of experience in the education sector. She goes on to say,

“Each school’s ranking is based on different criteria, making it critical that you take the time to see if the reason a university ranked highly is a factor that impacts you and your experience directly.”

It is critical to understand the limitations of college rankings and not depend on them alone when selecting your college, even if they provide useful information. With these rankings come several limitations.

Subjective Methodology

College rankings can greatly differ because different organizations employ different criteria to assess and rank schools. Some schools prioritize research outcomes, test prerequisites, or post-graduation employability. It is important to understand the ranking methodology to determine which aspects align with your priorities.

One-Size-Fits-All Approach

College rankings aim to provide a comprehensive evaluation of universities. However, each student has unique preferences and requirements. A highly reputed university may not offer the courses that cater to your needs. Conducting thorough research on the program, faculty members’ credentials, and the campus culture is important to make sure that it aligns with your career goals.

Context Gaps

College rankings are often incomplete because they do not consider each school’s unique qualities and complexities. They don’t consistently capture the intangible elements that make a school great, such as its location, campus culture, extracurricular activities, and a student’s personal preferences. 

A joyful woman in a graduation gown smiling and laughing

How to Leverage College Rankings?

To fully understand college rankings, it is important to do more than simply rely on the numbers. While they are helpful, it is important to recognize these rankings’ limitations and take a more comprehensive approach when assessing the value of your college education. To understand how to use college rankings effectively, consider various factors beyond the numerical order.

Think About Different Resources

To get a complete picture, it’s best to look at rankings from various sources, including Forbes, U.S. News & World Report, and Princeton Review. Comparing rankings from many sources provides a more complete picture as they utilize different criteria.

Focus on Your Program

Prioritize rankings that assess the quality of the program you have in mind. Find rankings specific to your field of study to get more accurate information that can help you achieve your academic objectives.

Visit Campuses 

Rankings only offer a general overview. To better understand a college or university, visiting the campus, attending open houses, and speaking with current students and faculty is best. This will allow you to assess whether the campus culture is a good match for you.

According to the BHDP survey, 95% of the respondents believe the campus visit significantly impacts prospective students’ enrollment decisions.

Connect with Alumni 

If you want to improve your decision-making skills, it is better to rely on real experiences rather than rankings. To gain more knowledge about the career paths available after college, networking with alumni, exploring internships, and attending educational seminars are recommended.

A college’s rating is a good way to gauge its reputation; however, it should not be the sole factor considered when choosing a college. Conducting thorough research while considering one’s personal preferences, goals, and fit is important for making an informed decision. 

While rankings can be helpful, a student’s commitment and the opportunities they take advantage of determine their educational journey.

Two students collaborating on a computer and a laptop

Frequently Asked Questions

Why Do Universities Use Rankings To Promote Themselves to Students?

Colleges get more exposure and credibility among prospective students when they use rankings. Higher rankings create a perception of academic excellence and quality for the institution.

What Is a Reliable Source for College Rankings?

Princeton Review, Forbes, and U.S. News & World Report are among the reliable sources for college ranking. However, it depends on individual preferences and specific factors important to the student seeking information.

What Role Does a University’s Rating Have in the Employment Market?

Universities with high scores often have strong connections with companies, which makes it easier to find internships and jobs after graduation. Furthermore, graduates from prestigious colleges are highly trusted by big firms, adding to their enormous market worth.


College rankings help students immensely in deciding the best college for higher studies. However, students must approach these rankings with a critical mindset and consider them as a source of valuable information and not the ultimate selection tool. 

Featured Programs

Aya Andrews


Aya Andrews is a passionate educator and mother of two, with a diverse background that has shaped her approach to teaching and learning. Born in Metro Manila, she now calls San Diego home and is proud to be a Filipino-American. Aya earned her Masters degree in Education from San Diego State University, where she focused on developing innovative teaching methods to engage and inspire students.

Prior to her work in education, Aya spent several years as a continuing education consultant for KPMG, where she honed her skills in project management and client relations. She brings this same level of professionalism and expertise to her work as an educator, where she is committed to helping each of her students achieve their full potential.

In addition to her work as an educator, Aya is a devoted mother who is passionate about creating a nurturing and supportive home environment for her children. She is an active member of her community, volunteering her time and resources to support local schools and organizations. Aya is also an avid traveler, and loves to explore new cultures and cuisines with her family.

With a deep commitment to education and a passion for helping others succeed, Aya is a true inspiration to those around her. Her dedication to her craft, her community, and her family is a testament to her unwavering commitment to excellence in all aspects of her life.

Find your perfect value college is an advertising-supported site. Featured or trusted partner programs and all school search, finder, or match results are for schools that compensate us. This compensation does not influence our school rankings, resource guides, or other editorially-independent information published on this site.

Enter a search word or phrase